Image shows hand holding pen on checklist of reading assessment data.

Oral Reading Fluency Assessments: What the Data Is Missing

After the flurry of beginning of year tests, learning about your students, and getting all the routines and procedures working like clockwork, we’re left with the real work.  Hefty work. The work of actually moving students forward as readers and writers.  So you look through that stack of Oral Reading Fluency assessments and think, “Now what? What do I DO with all of this data?” 

If this is you, know that you’re not alone.  

Why is this the case?  

Why doesn’t that stack of data help us know exactly what our next steps for each student should be?

Well, often because the data is missing key pieces of the information we need in order to get started on next steps.  The information we do have usually tells us a brief overview of skills, but it does not tell us the other important pieces we need. 

Things like strategies the student does have under control, whether or not they can glean “right there” information from the text, and how well they can read between the lines.  Things like whether vocabulary or lack of background knowledge might have been the barrier. These assessments don’t tell us much of anything in the way of what may be impacting comprehension, other than the most obvious–lack of decoding skills.  (for which no one needs a formal ORF assessment to ascertain).

Let’s focus on that Oral Reading Fluency Assessment (ORF), as it’s a very commonly used tool.

Its purpose is to quickly gauge how accurately and fluently a child can read what is considered a “grade level” text.  The assumption  is that if they can read it smoothly and accurately, it is likely that the child can also comprehend any text they read.  Which may or may not be true.

As students read for one minute, teachers are to cross off when an error is made–substitutions, mispronunciations, or omissions.  Insertions, oddly, are not counted as errors.  

And that’s it.  Teachers are not instructed to note anything else.  So you’re left with several possible scenarios.  Here are just some examples:

  • The child can read the text just fine, and is on track with rate.  But you have no idea if they actually understood it.
  • The child needed to work through a few words, using strategies they’ve acquired, which meant that while they read accurately, their rate went down. 
  • The child read very quickly, with little to no expression, but was 100% accurate.
  • The child struggled to read even the first couple of sentences, missing many of the words.

Now let’s unpack what the ORF directions will likely tell you to do next for each child.

For the child that read the words just fine and at a nice rate, we’re left to assume that comprehension is there.  But there’s no way to tell.

For the child that used a toolbox of strategies to figure out unknown words, assessor guidelines will tell you that because the child’s rate may have been a little slower, to do a phonics assessment next.

For the child that read with 100% accuracy and at a high rate, we’re left to assume that, like the first child, comprehension is on track.

And for the child that struggled a lot, the ORF told you nothing you didn’t already know.  You knew from day one that this child’s phonics skills were lacking, and had already planned to find out what they knew.  But you still have no idea what they’re able to comprehend.  

In general, an assessment like ORF is a quick and helpful tool.  It’s meant to tell you your next steps.  Stephanie Stollar lays out a flowchart for these steps in her book Reading Assessment Done Right.  Basically, if they struggle on ORF, do a phonics test.  If they struggle with phonics, do a phonemic awareness test.  And the kicker:  if they can read the grade level ORF text, “teach comprehension.” But what aspect of comprehension is a mystery.

There are additional assessments for comprehension out there.  

MAZE is purported to be a comprehension test, but it’s really just an assessment of a child’s command of grammatical structure and to some extent, vocabulary.  It’s not a measure of the broader range of comprehension skills we really need to understand. The Acadience CFOL does measure different aspects of comprehension, but there’s definitely a good amount of training involved to understand how it all works.  The Cubed-3 is my favorite tool for assessing comprehension, but there’s a big learning curve to it.  

Serravallo has a hot-off-the-press whole book assessment system, but not everyone can afford to buy a whole kit, and whole books mean this isn’t quick.  Another option?  One no one will want to hear, but is still pretty widely available in schools:  the Fountas and Pinnell Benchmark Assessment System (which you can get far more from with these tips). 

So…not a whole lot of options that are actually accessible, helpful, doable, or don’t take a ton of time. Which takes us right back to the original problem:  we need more useful information, not more assessments.  

What can we do then, without adding MORE assessments to our workload?  

Squeeze out more from the Oral Reading Fluency test.

When you give this assessment, don’t stop at merely crossing out words the child misses.  Conduct an actual running record, so you see the kinds of errors they make.  You’ll glean so much helpful information from this simple addition. 

Recording what a child’s attempts are, whether they reread, sound out, or appeal for help gives you something to go on.  Simply crossing out words a child missed will never give you this kind of critical information.  Many ORF tests don’t ask teachers to count insertions as errors.  These are absolutely errors, often caused by reading too quickly and then trying to make the text grammatically or semantically sensible. These insertions, in other words, are usually caused by the error that came before it.  Information well worth recording.

While you’re at it, take note of fluency, too.  As you make checkmarks for the words a child reads leave a larger space to denote what was phrased.  Or at the very least, jot yourself a quick note, like “2-3 word phrases” or “word by word.”  This is the time to note missed or inserted punctuation, and stress on words that shouldn’t be stressed.  It’s also where you can jot down notes about their expression.  

Those notes can capture a lot. 

Without them, you won’t remember what reading strategies they have under their belt, nor will you remember what parts of words they get right and what they miss.  And you sure won’t have any idea why.  Is there b/d confusion?  Are they dropping inflectional endings? Going too quickly and missing high frequency words?  There are a multitude of reasons why a child might make errors, and it’s not always because of lack of phonics skills.  

But what about comprehension? 

You can use the ORF for a general sense of comprehension too.  Instead of stopping at the one minute mark, have the child finish the text, if they’re able to read it well enough.  Alternatively, you can finish reading the text for them.  Then, ask them to retell or summarize it.  

These assessments are not designed to gauge comprehension, but we can capture a snapshot of it.  In terms of quick and informal, it will at least tell you if the child understood what they read/heard.  You’ll also see what parts they understood–did they hold onto the beginning only?  The end?  Did they get the people mixed up?  The big events?  Were they confused by unfamiliar vocabulary?  It’s not a perfect measure of comprehension, but it’s a start.

At the end of the day, we need to understand more than just how many words a child can read in a minute. In order to make next-step instructional decisions, we need to understand what students already know how to do as readers and where they get stuck. In a classroom of 20+ kids, this is why it’s important to make the most of the materials–including the assessments–that we’re already using.  

Are you feeling like your literacy block is packed with too much to do and not enough time to do it? You don’t have to figure it all out alone! I help experienced elementary teachers simplify literacy instruction and create practical solutions that work in their classrooms–practical solutions just like this post. Interested in learning how we can work together? Click here!


Coach from the couch in pink and white sweater holding white coffee mug to offer 1:1 literacy coaching services.

Who is Coach from the Couch?  I’m Michelle Ruhe, a 25+ year educator and currently a K-5 literacy coach.  I continue to learn alongside teachers in classrooms each and every day, and it’s my mission to support as many teachers with this hard work as I can.  

Add A Comment